Practical guide
Award criteria: price, cost and best price-quality ratio
The criteria on which the most economically advantageous tender may be chosen, when the lowest price alone is enough, and what must be stated in advance on weighting, scoring and ties (Sections 76–78 of the Kbt.).
Legal basisSection 76(1) · Section 76(2) · Section 76(3) · Section 76(5) · Section 76(6) · Section 76(9) · Section 76(10) · Section 77(1) · Section 77(2) · Section 77(4) · Section 77(5) · Section 78(1) · official text
In the contract notice (eljárást megindító felhívás) the contracting authority sets the criteria on which it will choose the tender that is, for it, the most economically advantageous, where relevant also from a social, societal and environmental point of view; these are the award criteria (értékelési szempontok) (Kbt. Section 76(1)). This guide explains the three possible sets of criteria, when the lowest price alone is enough, what requirements the criteria must meet, and what must be fixed in advance on weighting, scoring and breaking ties.
Three sets of criteria
The following may be used as award criteria (Kbt. Section 76(2)):
- the lowest price;
- the lowest cost, calculated by a cost-effectiveness method set by the contracting authority;
- criteria representing the best price-quality ratio (legjobb ár-érték arány), in particular qualitative, environmental and social criteria, which include the price or cost.
The lowest price only by exception
As a rule, the lowest cost or the best price-quality ratio must be used. The lowest price may be the only criterion where the contracting authority's needs are met by supplies or services meeting specifically defined quality and technical requirements, and where further quality features would not serve the choice of the most economically advantageous tender, only the evaluation of the lowest price would. The lowest price may not be the only criterion for design, engineering and architectural services, or for works. For certain subjects, legislation adopted under the Kbt., or the conditions of a grant for a grant-funded procurement, may lay down detailed rules on the criteria and the method (Kbt. Section 76(5)).
In competitive dialogue, in an innovation partnership and in a negotiated procedure without publication under Section 98(5), which follows a design contest, only criteria representing the best price-quality ratio may be used (Kbt. Section 90(6), Kbt. Section 96(4), Kbt. Section 100(3)).
What may be evaluated
Criteria representing the best price-quality ratio may relate in particular to (Kbt. Section 76(3)):
- quality, technical merit, aesthetic and functional characteristics, accessibility for all users, the employment of disadvantaged workers and other social, environmental and innovative characteristics, trading conditions, after-sales service and technical assistance, the supply of spare parts, security of supply, and the date or period of delivery (Kbt. Section 76(3)(a));
- the organisation, qualifications and experience of the staff assigned to perform the contract, where the quality of the staff can have a significant impact on the level of performance (Kbt. Section 76(3)(b)).
The price or cost may also be fixed in advance, so that tenderers compete only on the other criteria (Kbt. Section 76(4)). A criterion is linked to the subject-matter of the contract where it relates to the works, supplies or services in any respect and at any stage of their life cycle, even where it does not determine the material characteristics of the result (Kbt. Section 76(7)); for instance, the proposed level of employment of jobseekers, or training of unemployed people as part of performance, may be evaluated (Kbt. Section 76(8)).
Requirements the criteria must meet
The award criteria (Kbt. Section 76(6)):
- must be linked to the subject-matter of the contract;
- may not give the contracting authority an unrestricted freedom of choice, but must rest on factors that can be assessed on quantitative or professional grounds;
- must ensure compliance with the principles of Section 2(1)–(5);
- may not evaluate the tenderer's suitability to perform the contract; where staff are evaluated and a selection criterion also relates to them, the minimum required for performance must be clearly separated from what is evaluated above it;
- may not lead to the same element of a tender being evaluated more than once.
The contracting authority must also set requirements that allow it to verify how far a tender meets the criteria, and in case of doubt it must satisfy itself that the information provided is accurate (Kbt. Section 76(13)).
What the contract notice must state
Unless the lowest price alone, or the lowest cost determined by the method of Section 78 alone, decides, the contracting authority must set (Kbt. Section 76(9)):
- the award criteria and their weightings (súlyszám), proportionate to the actual importance of each criterion (Kbt. Section 76(9)(a));
- the lower and upper limits of the score that may be given, the same for every criterion (Kbt. Section 76(9)(c));
- the method or methods by which it gives the score between those limits (Kbt. Section 76(9)(d)).
These must be given in the contract notice; the detailed description of the method may also be given in the other procurement documents. Exceptionally, where weighting is not possible for objective reasons and the contracting authority clearly substantiates this in the notice, the criteria must be listed in decreasing order of importance and the evaluation method must be described in the procurement documents (Kbt. Section 76(10)). The Public Procurement Authority (Közbeszerzési Hatóság) prepares guidance on the methods and on the assessment of tenders (Kbt. Section 76(12)).
Most favourable level and minimum requirement
For criteria other than price or cost, the contracting authority may set in the notice the most favourable level of an element of the tender for which, and for any still more favourable commitment, it gives the same score as the upper limit. For any criterion, and, except for lump-sum contracts, for the unit prices or costs that are not evaluated separately but fix the consideration payable under the contract, it may also set a requirement below which the element may not fall (Kbt. Section 77(1)).
Calculating the total score
The contracting authority scores the evaluated elements of each tender between the limits given in the notice, by the method it has set, multiplies each score by the weighting and adds up the products for each tender: the tender with the highest total score is the most favourable (Kbt. Section 77(2)). If it said so in the notice in advance, it may hold an electronic auction after the evaluation (Kbt. Section 77(3)).
Life-cycle cost
Where the contracting authority determines cost by life-cycle costing, it says so in the notice and states in the procurement documents which data tenderers must provide and which method it will use (Kbt. Section 78(1)). The costs of acquisition, of use (in particular consumption of energy and other resources), of maintenance and of the end of life may be taken into account, as may costs of environmental externalities where their monetary value can be determined and verified (Kbt. Section 78(2)). The method used for externalities must be objectively verifiable, set in advance and accessible to all, and the data it needs must be obtainable with reasonable effort (Kbt. Section 78(3)).
Ties
The contracting authority may set in the procurement documents an objective method or a supplementary criterion to decide a tie. If it did not, the most favourable tender is the one that scored more on the criterion with the highest weighting among those on which the scores were not equal; and where the lowest price is the criterion, a draw held in the presence of a notary decides. The contracting authority may also hold such a draw where the most favourable tender still cannot be determined (Kbt. Section 77(5)).
The winner and the contract
The winner is the tenderer who submitted the most favourable tender under the award criteria, provided its tender is valid (Kbt. Section 77(4)); only tenders found compliant in the examination may be evaluated (Kbt. Section 69(3)). At the opening of tenders, the main quantifiable data to be evaluated must be read out (Kbt. Section 68(4)); the tenderer may not prohibit their disclosure (Kbt. Section 44(3)); and the contract must contain the evaluated elements of the winning tender (Kbt. Section 131(2)).
In practice
- It is good practice to test the method with trial calculations before the notice is published: they show whether the weightings really reflect the actual importance of the criteria (Kbt. Section 76(9)(a)), and whether dropping one tender would change the relative ranking of the others. On the latter depends whether the second-best tenderer may also be invited to submit certificates (Kbt. Section 69(6)); see the guide on the written summary and the standstill period.
- Where a selection criterion and an award criterion concern the same circumstance (such as the experience of experts), it is worth stating the minimum and the evaluated surplus separately in the notice (Kbt. Section 76(6)(d)); on replacing experts, see the guide on missing documents.
- The examination of abnormally low prices is, as a rule, part of the assessment of tenders, but in an open procedure it may follow the evaluation if the documents so provide (Kbt. Section 81(4)); see the guide on abnormally low tenders. Common questions are answered in the FAQ on choosing the winner.
Related pages
Previous guide
Abnormally low prices and other disproportionate commitments
Next guide
Written summary, conclusion of the contract and the standstill period
Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Ellenőrzés does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Kbt. in force. Not legal advice.