FAQ
Choosing the winner
Questions and answers on the criteria tenders are evaluated on, how the total score is calculated, who wins the procedure and what happens in a tie.
Choosing the winner takes two steps: in the examination of tenders (bírálat) the contracting authority establishes which tenders meet the requirements, and it then evaluates those tenders against the award criteria (Kbt. Section 69(3)). The guide on award criteria explains in detail how the criteria, the weightings and the scoring method are chosen, and the guide on abnormally low tenders how prices that seem too low are examined.
The contracting authority communicates the outcome in the written summary (írásbeli összegezés), and as a rule may not conclude the contract before the standstill period (szerződéskötési moratórium) has ended; the guide on the written summary and the standstill period explains both.
On what basis is the winner chosen?
On the basis of the most economically advantageous tender, which the contracting authority chooses by the lowest price, the lowest cost or criteria representing the best price-quality ratio (Kbt. Section 76(2)). The criteria must be set in the contract notice (eljárást megindító felhívás) (Kbt. Section 76(1)).
Legal basisSection 76(2) · Section 76(1) · official text
What must be stated in advance on weighting and scoring?
Unless the lowest price alone, or the lowest cost determined by the method of Section 78 alone, decides, the criteria and their weightings, proportionate to their actual importance, the score limits, the same for every criterion, and the scoring method must be stated (Kbt. Section 76(9)). They must be given in the contract notice; the detailed description of the method may also be given in the other procurement documents (Kbt. Section 76(10)).
Legal basisSection 76(9) · Section 76(10) · official text
May the tenderer's references or experience be evaluated?
The tenderer's suitability to perform the contract may not be evaluated (Kbt. Section 76(6)(d)). The organisation, qualifications and experience of the staff assigned to perform the contract may be, where the quality of the staff can have a significant impact on the level of performance (Kbt. Section 76(3)(b)); the minimum required (the selection criterion) must then be clearly separated from what is evaluated above it (Kbt. Section 76(6)(d)).
Legal basisSection 76(6)(d) · Section 76(3)(b) · official text
How is the most favourable tender worked out?
The contracting authority scores the evaluated elements between the score limits by the method set in the notice, multiplies each score by the weighting and adds up the products for each tender; the tender with the highest total score is the most favourable (Kbt. Section 77(2)).
Legal basisSection 77(2) · official text
What happens if two tenders have the same total score?
The method or supplementary criterion the contracting authority set for this in the procurement documents decides. If it set none, the tender that scored more on the criterion with the highest weighting, among those on which the scores were not equal, wins; where the lowest price is the criterion, a draw held in the presence of a notary decides (Kbt. Section 77(5)).
Legal basisSection 77(5) · official text
Who wins the procedure?
The tenderer who submitted the most favourable tender under the award criteria, provided its tender is valid (Kbt. Section 77(4)). Only a tenderer that, at the contracting authority's request, has properly submitted the certificates on exclusion grounds and selection criteria may be named the winner (Kbt. Section 69(5)).
Legal basisSection 77(4) · Section 69(5) · official text
What becomes of the evaluated commitments of the winning tender?
The contract must contain the elements of the winning tender that were evaluated (Kbt. Section 131(2)). The tenderer may not prohibit the disclosure of evaluated data, even by claiming business secrecy (Kbt. Section 44(3)).
Legal basisSection 131(2) · Section 44(3) · official text
Related pages
Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Ellenőrzés does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Kbt. in force. Not legal advice.