FAQ
Review requests and prior dispute resolution
Short answers on who may challenge a decision of the contracting authority, when and how, with the contracting authority and before the Public Procurement Arbitration Board, and what happens to the contract meanwhile.
Remedies work at two levels: prior dispute resolution (előzetes vitarendezés) with the contracting authority, and a request for review (jogorvoslati kérelem) before the Public Procurement Arbitration Board (Közbeszerzési Döntőbizottság), whose decisions the courts can review. The steps, the content of a request, interim measures and the Board's time limits are set out in the guide on remedies.
The time limits are short and forfeit the right to apply when missed, so it is good practice to calculate them as soon as the written summary of the evaluation of tenders (írásbeli összegezés) arrives. The FAQ on counting time limits sets out how they are counted, and the guide to the written summary and the standstill period explains how the summary and the standstill period fit together.
What is prior dispute resolution, and until when can it be requested?
It is a request to the contracting authority, submitted through the EKR, that identifies the decision, document or procedural act considered unlawful and makes a proposal (Kbt. Section 80(2), Kbt. Section 80(3)). A tenderer or candidate may submit it within three working days of learning of the infringing event (Kbt. Section 80(1)(a)); any interested economic operator may challenge the contract notice and the procurement documents until the tenth day before the time limit for tenders or requests to participate (Kbt. Section 80(1)(b)(ba)). The contracting authority answers within three working days (Kbt. Section 80(3)).
Legal basisSection 80(2) · Section 80(3) · Section 80(1)(a) · Section 80(1)(b)(ba) · official text
Is prior dispute resolution required before a request for review?
The Kbt. does not make it a condition of a request for review: it frames prior dispute resolution as an entitlement (Kbt. Section 80(1)), and a request for review must state any prior dispute resolution that took place, attaching the contracting authority's answer (Kbt. Section 149(1)(h)). Where the requester used it and the contracting authority took no measure beyond answering, the infringement is deemed known on the date the answer was sent, or, if there was no answer, on the date the time limit for answering expired (Kbt. Section 148(7)(d)).
Legal basisSection 80(1) · Section 149(1)(h) · Section 148(7)(d) · official text
Who may submit a request for review?
The contracting authority, a tenderer (in a joint tender, any of the tenderers), a candidate, or any other interested party, whose rights or legitimate interests are infringed or threatened by an act or omission contrary to the Kbt. (Kbt. Section 148(2)). Against the contract notice, the procurement documents and their modification, a chamber or interest group whose activity is related to the subject-matter of the procurement may also apply (Kbt. Section 148(2)).
Legal basisSection 148(2) · official text
How long is there to submit a request for review?
As a rule, fifteen days from learning of the infringement, and ten days against the decision closing the procedure (Kbt. Section 148(3)); in a procedure under Section 115, five days against the closing decision (Kbt. Section 148(4)). For the infringements of Section 137(1), such as unlawfully dispensing with a procurement procedure, thirty days, and no later than one year from the conclusion of the contract (Kbt. Section 148(9)). Missing a time limit forfeits the right to apply (Kbt. Section 148(10)).
Legal basisSection 148(3) · Section 148(4) · Section 148(9) · Section 148(10) · official text
Until when can the contract notice or the procurement documents be challenged?
Until the fifth day before the time limit for tenders or requests to participate, as modified where applicable; if the fifteen-day period ends later, until then (Kbt. Section 148(5)). The date of knowledge is then the date the notice was published, the direct invitation was received or the documents were made available (Kbt. Section 148(7)(a)).
Legal basisSection 148(5) · Section 148(7)(a) · official text
Is a representative needed before the Board, and what must be attached to the request?
Yes: representation by a state public procurement adviser, an in-house legal counsel registered with the bar (kamarai jogtanácsos) or an attorney is mandatory (Kbt. Section 145(7)). For each element of the request, the request must state among other things when the infringement occurred and became known, the provision infringed and the evidence (Kbt. Section 149(1)); proof of payment of the administrative service fee must be attached (Kbt. Section 150(1)), and the contracting authority must be notified before the request is submitted (Kbt. Section 148(12)).
Legal basisSection 145(7) · Section 149(1) · Section 150(1) · Section 148(12) · official text
Can the contract be concluded while review proceedings are pending?
No: once a request for review or an ex officio initiative is submitted, the contract – for tenders by lots, the contract for the lot concerned – may not be concluded until the decision on the merits or the decision ending the case is adopted (Kbt. Section 131(7)). The exception is where the Board, at the contracting authority's request, authorises it by order because of an urgent and overriding interest or public interest (Kbt. Section 156(4)).
Legal basisSection 131(7) · Section 156(4) · official text
What can the Public Procurement Arbitration Board decide?
It may reject an unfounded request or find that an infringement occurred (Kbt. Section 165(2)). Where it finds an infringement, it may call on the infringer to proceed in line with the Kbt., annul a decision of the contracting authority taken during the procedure or closing it, provided the contract has not yet been concluded, and impose a fine (Kbt. Section 165(3)). Where it annuls the closing decision, the contracting authority must take a new decision within thirty days (Kbt. Section 165(12)).
Legal basisSection 165(2) · Section 165(3) · Section 165(12) · official text
Can the Board's decision be taken to court?
Yes: an administrative court action may be brought against the decision on the merits; the statement of claim must be filed within fifteen days of service of the decision, with the Board only (Kbt. Section 170(2)). The court's judgment may be appealed only if it changes the Board's decision (Kbt. Section 172(6)).
Legal basisSection 170(2) · Section 172(6) · official text
Related pages
Previous topic
Questions from tenderers
Next topic
Concluding, modifying and performing a public contract
Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Ellenőrzés does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Kbt. in force. Not legal advice.