Practical guide
Selection criteria
Which criteria on economic and financial standing and on technical and professional ability a contracting authority may set, how far they may go, and how a tenderer may rely on the capacity of other entities.
Legal basisSection 65(1) · Section 65(2) · Section 65(3) · Section 65(4) · Section 65(5) · Section 65(6) · Section 65(7) · Section 65(8) · Section 65(9) · Section 65(10) · Section 138(2) · Section 114(1) · official text
Selection criteria (alkalmassági követelmények) test whether a tenderer or candidate is able to perform the contract. This guide explains the areas in which a contracting authority may set such criteria under Section 65 of the Kbt., what counts as proportionate, how joint tenderers may meet the criteria together, and on what terms a tenderer may rely on the capacity of other entities.
What they may cover
The contracting authority may set selection criteria on:
- economic and financial standing (Kbt. Section 65(1)(a));
- technical and professional ability (Kbt. Section 65(1)(b));
- where performance requires it, enrolment in a register of the country of establishment, or holding an authorisation, licence or membership of an organisation or chamber required there (Kbt. Section 65(1)(c)).
The authority may dispense with criteria on technical and professional ability only in an exceptional case, justified in the procurement documents (közbeszerzési dokumentumok), where the specific features of the purchase make them unnecessary for proper performance; no separate justification is needed where, on the legal ground of a negotiated procedure without prior publication, only specified operators may be invited to tender (Kbt. Section 65(2)).
The criteria must be stated precisely in the notice launching the procedure, which must also say which circumstances – their presence, absence or the degree of their shortfall – rule out suitability. The documents to be submitted as proof must be specified precisely in the notice or – with a brief indication of their type in the notice – in the other procurement documents (Kbt. Section 65(2)).
Proportionality
The criteria must be limited to the subject-matter of the procurement, with due regard to equal opportunity, equal treatment and fair competition, and – also in the light of the estimated value – may go no further than what is actually needed to perform the contract (Kbt. Section 65(3)). In two cases the Kbt. gives figures for what is actually needed (Kbt. Section 65(5)):
- References: a requirement counts as no more than actually needed if it asks for proof of earlier supplies, works or services that are technically equivalent in subject-matter, with a value of at most 75% of the value of the procurement – or, where quantities are used, at most 75% of its quantity or extent.
- Turnover: an operator may not be found unsuitable if its total turnover over the business year or years examined reaches the value of the procurement, or – where turnover in the subject-matter is examined – if that turnover reaches 75% of that value.
In both cases the value of the procurement is counted without applying Section 19(3), that is, without aggregating the lots (Kbt. Section 65(5)).
The details are in a government decree
The possible means of proving suitability and the detailed requirements for setting selection criteria are laid down in separate legislation (Kbt. Section 65(4)): the Kbt. empowers the Government, which also sets by decree the means of proof a contracting authority must accept and the documents it may ask for (Kbt. Section 69(10), Kbt. Section 198(1), point 1). When drafting a particular criterion, the implementing government decree must therefore be read as well; the Kbt. itself sets only the framework described here.
Joint tenderers
Joint tenderers or joint candidates may meet the selection criteria together; for criteria that by their nature can only apply to each operator individually, it is enough that one of them meets them (Kbt. Section 65(6)). If one of them leaves after the time limit for tenders or requests to participate, the others may continue only if they still meet every selection criterion and fair competition is not harmed (Kbt. Section 35(7)).
Relying on the capacity of other entities
A tenderer may meet the selection criteria by relying on the capacity of any other entity or person, whatever the legal nature of the link between them (Kbt. Section 65(7)). To do so:
- the tender (or request to participate) must name the entity and – referring to the relevant point of the notice – the criterion for which its resources are relied on (Kbt. Section 65(7));
- it must include the entity's commitment, made in a contract, preliminary contract or other form, showing that the resources will be available throughout performance (Kbt. Section 65(7)); the commitment must also authorise the tenderer to make declarations on the entity's behalf in the EKR (elektronikus közbeszerzési rendszer, the electronic public procurement system) (Kbt. Section 65(12));
- the entity must also submit a European Single Procurement Document, and when evidence is requested it must prove – for the selection criteria only – that it meets the criterion concerned by the means of proof required (Kbt. Section 67(3)).
Special rules:
- Economic and financial standing: the commitment of point 2 is not required (Kbt. Section 65(7)), but the entity whose data are used is liable as a guarantor (kezes), under Section 6:419 of the Civil Code (Ptk.), for the damage the contracting authority suffers if the tenderer fails to perform or performs defectively (Kbt. Section 65(8)); the EKR authorisation must then be included in the tender itself (Kbt. Section 65(12)).
- Experts and references: another entity's capacity may be relied on only if that entity takes part in performance to an extent that – together with the tenderer's own capacity – ensures the required expertise or professional experience is actually applied; an entity lending a reference must actually take part in performance, which the authority checks while the contract is performed (Kbt. Section 65(9)).
- Registration, authorisation, membership: another entity's capacity may be relied on if that entity carries out the task for which they are required (Kbt. Section 65(9)).
- Critical tasks: in works and services contracts, and for siting or installation operations under a supply contract, the authority may require certain critical tasks to be performed by the tenderer itself (or, in a joint tender, by one of the joint tenderers); for those tasks no other entity's capacity may be relied on to prove the requirements of the two points above, and no subcontractor may perform them (Kbt. Section 65(10)).
In the same procedure – and, where tenders for lots are allowed, for the same lot – a tenderer may not prove the suitability of another tenderer (Kbt. Section 36(1)(c)). A legal successor may not use its predecessor's data if an exclusion ground applicable in the procedure existed for the predecessor at the time of succession and still exists, unless it proves its reliability through self-cleaning (Kbt. Section 65(11)).
During performance
The winning tenderer must involve in performance the entity that helped prove its suitability, in line with that entity's commitment, and the experts it presented as proof. They may be dropped or replaced only if the tenderer, without them or with the new entity or expert, still meets the criteria it met with them in the procedure – and, where the authority used those data to limit the number of participants, meets them in an equivalent way (Kbt. Section 138(2)). The guide to subcontractors covers this in more detail.
Proof, and procedures below the EU thresholds
The tenderer first declares its suitability in the European Single Procurement Document and submits the evidence when the contracting authority asks for it (Kbt. Section 67(1), Kbt. Section 69(4)); the guide to the ESPD sets out the order. Below the EU thresholds the authority is not obliged to set selection criteria (Kbt. Section 114(1)), and in the procedure of Section 115, available for works with an estimated value below three hundred million forints, it may not set any (Kbt. Section 115(2)). A tender is invalid if the tenderer does not meet the selection criteria or has not properly proved that it does (Kbt. Section 73(1)(d)); the exclusion grounds are covered in the guide to exclusion grounds.
Related pages
Want your tender documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Ellenőrzés does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Kbt. in force. Not legal advice.